What’s Really In The Data On AI And Graduate Job Opportunities?
AIThis post was created with the assistance of artificial intelligence (AI).

🔍 Read the full analysis: What’s Really In The Data On AI And Graduate Job Opportunities? on ThorstenMeyerAI.com

Buying for a business?Offer from Amazon

Get business pricing on tech for your team

  • Business-only prices and quantity discounts
  • Tax-exempt purchasing
  • Multiple users, one account, clear invoices
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.

TL;DR

UK job adverts have fallen more in occupations considered highly exposed to AI than in less-exposed roles, while Australian graduate postings also weakened. The figures show a hiring pattern, not proof that AI caused it; economic and labour-market changes are competing explanations.

UK online job adverts have fallen more in occupations with high exposure to artificial intelligence than in occupations with low exposure, according to a Bank of England staff analysis, while Australian graduate postings have also declined. The figures point to pressure on some entry-level work, but do not establish that AI caused the drop, a distinction that matters to graduates, employers and universities weighing how quickly the technology is changing early-career hiring.

In an August 6 post on the Bank of England’s Bank Underground blog, staff analyst Haley Schlicht compared UK online job adverts with an AI-exposure score for occupations. Adverts fell 15% in the most-exposed third of occupations, compared with 10% in the middle third and 6% in the least-exposed third. Customer service adverts fell 23%, while administrative adverts fell 22%. The analysis describes the staff member’s findings, not a formal determination by the Bank’s Monetary Policy Committee.

The pattern is consistent with weaker demand for jobs that include routine information processing, correspondence and scheduling, tasks that may be affected by AI tools. But Schlicht cautioned that the evidence for AI changing hiring is less firm than headlines imply. Pandemic-era over-hiring, an economic slowdown, remote work, an energy shock and higher labour costs are among the factors that overlapped with the hiring decline. The analysis says “confident attribution remains premature.”

Australia offers a similar signal, with important qualifications. The source material reports that graduate job postings fell almost 15% in 2025 and fell more in AI-exposed jobs. It also says the decline began in 2023, before widespread AI adoption, and that apprenticeships fell 46% from their peak, according to Indeed, despite having little exposure to AI. Those figures suggest broader weakness in early-career hiring may also be at work.

At a glance
reportWhen: Data and analysis reported as of Novemb…
The developmentA review of UK and Australian hiring data finds sharper declines in some AI-exposed occupations, while the evidence remains insufficient to attribute those declines to AI.

AI and the entry level · explainer

From career pyramid to diamond

Why the first rung of the ladder is where AI could show up first, and why the cause is not settled yet.

A workforce by level (schematic)

Senior Junior AI takes tasks

Pyramid: many juniors at the basedoing scheduling, correspondence and routine information processing UK job adverts: −15% vs −6%in the most vs the least AI-exposed third of occupations Diamond: hollow at the base“centred on experienced staff”

How the squeeze could work

  1. First jobsRoutine tasks: scheduling, correspondence, routine information processingthe base of the pyramid
  2. AI steps inSenior workers can do more of the work that once formed the bedrock of junior hiringBank Underground
  3. Fewer advertsUK online job adverts fell 15% in the most AI-exposed third, 6% in the leastBank Underground, ONS data
  4. DiamondThe pyramid may turn into a diamond, hollow at the baseBank Underground
  5. Not settledPandemic over-hiring, the business cycle, remote work and labour costs hit at the same time“confident attribution remains premature”
The open question for employers: if the base hollows out, who becomes the experienced staff of the next decade?

Source: Haley Schlicht, Bank of England, Bank Underground blog, Aug 6, 2026 (staff view, not necessarily the Bank’s), based on ONS online job adverts through early 2026; the pyramid-to-diamond idea is from research the post cites. The blocks are a schematic, not data. The question in the orange box is ours.

Graphic: Powered by Thorsten Meyer AI

Pressure on the First Career Rung

If demand continues to weaken in roles that have traditionally offered graduates their first professional experience, the effects could reach beyond the number of vacancies. Early jobs help workers build skills, learn workplace practices and qualify for more senior positions. A thinner entry-level pipeline could leave employers with fewer experienced workers later, though the available figures do not show that this outcome has occurred.

The data also matters for students choosing courses and universities deciding how to prepare graduates. A November 15 article in The Conversation by Armin D Ashenberg, a senior lecturer in law and emerging technologies at Western Sydney University, argues that graduates will need to judge the quality of AI output, identify its shortcomings and improve it. That is an expert’s assessment of what education should emphasize, not evidence that employers have already removed particular jobs because of AI.

For employers, the question is not only whether AI can handle tasks now assigned to junior staff, but how organizations will train future specialists if fewer juniors are hired. The current evidence supports monitoring hiring patterns; it does not settle how much of the change reflects automation rather than a weaker labour market.

Products Worth Considering

Bose Portable Smart Speaker with Alexa and Google Assistant, Black

Bose Portable Smart Speaker with Alexa and Google Assistant, Black

As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.

Warnings and Official Forecasts

The data has drawn attention amid two recent warnings. Ashenberg’s article, published in The Conversation on November 15, examined the implications of AI for graduates and universities. Separately, The Telegraph published a November 13 story reporting that the head of the UK Office for Budget Responsibility had warned of “very painful” job losses from AI. The reporting reviewed for this article could not independently verify those remarks: the story was behind a paywall, and no OBR or parliamentary record containing the statement was found. The warning should therefore be treated as The Telegraph’s reported account, not a confirmed OBR position.

The OBR’s October 2026 Economic and fiscal outlook provides a more qualified public assessment. Its central forecast is that AI will boost productivity growth by 0.2 percentage points a year by the medium term, while saying the scale and timing of any effect are highly uncertain. Citing the Office for National Statistics, it reported that 30% of businesses said they used at least one type of AI technology in September 2026, up from 15% two years earlier.

Separate ONS figures show 691,000 UK vacancies in July to September 2026, a decline of 21,000, or 2.9%, from the previous quarter. The ONS said smaller firms may not be recruiting because of higher labour costs. Those numbers describe the wider vacancies market; they do not identify AI as the cause of the fall.

““Confident attribution remains premature.””

— Haley Schlicht, Bank of England Data and Statistics Division, in the Bank Underground blog

What the Hiring Figures Cannot Prove

The central unknown is how much of the decline in adverts and graduate postings is attributable to AI. The UK analysis compares changes across occupations grouped by exposure; it does not isolate AI from other economic forces or establish that employers replaced workers with AI. The Australian pattern also began before widespread AI adoption, while the reported apprenticeship decline points to strain in roles with little AI exposure.

Measures of exposure are not the same as counts of jobs automated. An occupation can involve tasks that AI may assist with without being eliminated, and job-ad data captures advertised openings rather than every hiring decision or the number of workers employed. The source material does not provide enough detail to determine how changes in posting practices affected the figures.

The reported OBR chief’s warning also remains unverified in the available records described by the source. The OBR’s published forecast recognizes possible productivity gains but explicitly says the effects on productivity and employment remain uncertain. No firm estimate of AI-related graduate job losses is established by the evidence cited here.

Further Hiring Data to Watch

The OBR says it will closely monitor emerging evidence for its productivity and employment forecasts. Future updates to official vacancy and employment statistics, alongside continued analysis of job adverts by occupation, may help show whether the gap between high- and low-AI-exposure roles persists as the technology spreads.

For now, the evidence supports a measured conclusion: entry-level hiring is weak in some areas, and the declines are sharper in occupations classified as more exposed to AI. It does not show that AI is the sole, or even the main, cause. Establishing that would require evidence that separates technology adoption from wider changes in demand, costs and recruitment.

Key Questions

Does the data prove AI is causing graduate job losses?

No. UK adverts fell more in occupations rated highly exposed to AI, but the Bank of England analysis says confident attribution is premature. The figures show a relationship, not proof of cause.

Which UK occupations had the biggest advert declines?

In the Bank Underground analysis, customer service adverts fell 23% and administrative adverts fell 22%. Across exposure groups, adverts dropped 15% in the most-exposed third and 6% in the least-exposed third.

What does the Australian data show?

The source material reports that graduate job postings fell almost 15% in 2025, with larger declines in AI-exposed jobs. The decline began in 2023, before widespread AI adoption, and apprenticeships also fell sharply from their peak.

Has the OBR confirmed a warning of very painful job losses?

That warning was reported by The Telegraph, but the source material says it could not be independently verified in an OBR or parliamentary record. The OBR’s published October forecast says AI’s effects on productivity and employment remain highly uncertain.

Source: ThorstenMeyerAI.com

You May Also Like

Orthopedic Post-Op Recovery: A Guide To Monitoring Your Progress

A new recovery-percentile tracker for post-surgical orthopedic patients aims to reduce calls and improve patient reassurance through objective data.

What’s Confirmed About Anthropic’s Reported Gas Generator Deal?

Piper Sandler confirms a $3.4 billion OnePWR sale to an unnamed AI lab. The FT identifies Anthropic as buyer, but key details remain unknown.

7 Things You Need To Know About Grok Bot And Elon Musk’s AI Ambitions

Exploring Grok Bot’s emergence as Musk’s AI competitor to Claude Cowork, its capabilities, development status, and implications for AI in workplaces.

Insurers Claim AI Is Already Increasing Healthcare Costs

BCBSA analysis finds hospital AI coding added $942M in spending over two years, citing a gap between documented conditions and care delivered.